171
Part Four · Quantum biology

DNA mutation and proton tunneling

DNA’s bases pair through hydrogen bonds: guanine with cytosine, adenine with thymine. In 1963 Per-Olov Löwdin suggested that the protons in those bonds could tunnel across to the partner base, briefly turning each base into a rare tautomer that pairs with the wrong partner. If a replicating polymerase arrived at that moment, it could copy the mismatch: a spontaneous mutation, from quantum tunnelling. It is an arresting link between quantum physics, cancer and evolution. Sixty years on, the tautomers are known to exist; how much tunnelling contributes, and whether it matters for real mutation rates, is unsettled.

On the plate: a proton’s double well in a base pair.

Tautomers and mispairs

In the G–C pair, two protons sit in hydrogen bonds between the bases. If both move across together, a double proton transfer, the result is G*–C*, both in their rare tautomeric forms. Normally the canonical form is lower in energy by a few tenths of an eV, so the tautomer is rare and short-lived. If the strands separate while the tautomer persists, G* can pair with thymine instead of cytosine, a transition mutation after the next round of copying. In 2015 Isaac Kimsey, Hashim Al-Hashimi and colleagues used NMR relaxation dispersion to detect rare, transient Watson–Crick-like mispairs in DNA, formed by tautomerization or ionization, at populations around 0.1–1% and lifetimes of milliseconds or less. Established that such mispairs occur.

A double well with a bath

Model the proton as a particle in an asymmetric double well, with energy offset 0.30 eV and barrier 0.60 eV, coupled to the thermal motion of the surrounding DNA and water at 310 K. Tunnelling: . Two quantities matter: the equilibrium tautomer fraction, ≈e−ΔE/kBT\approx e^{-\Delta E/k_BT}, which tunnelling does not change; and how quickly that equilibrium is reached, which it does. In 2022 Louie Slocombe, Marco Sacchi and Jim Al-Khalili, modelling the G–C pair as an open quantum system, found that tunnelling makes the tautomer form within picoseconds and populate it far more than classical estimates. Debated

Does it cause mutations?

For a tautomer to become a mutation it must survive until a polymerase reads it, and the tautomer is also short-lived: if it decays back in picoseconds while strand separation takes much longer, the polymerase meets the canonical form. Some modelling suggests tautomers can persist through strand separation in some cases; others find they revert first. Polymerases also check base-pair geometry, and repair enzymes fix many mismatches. Spontaneous mutation rates, about 10−1010^{-10} per base per replication in humans after proofreading and repair, have many contributing causes. Whether proton tunnelling contributes a measurable share is not known. Speculative for a role in real mutation rates.

What you now have

Löwdin’s tautomer hypothesis, double proton transfer in G–C, the experimental detection of transient mispairs, an open-system double-well model separating equilibrium populations from rates, and the gap between tautomer formation and mutation.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

Does tunnelling change the equilibrium tautomer fraction?tap
No; it changes how fast equilibrium is reached, not the Boltzmann ratio.
What was detected experimentally in 2015?tap
Rare, transient Watson–Crick-like mispairs, by NMR relaxation dispersion.
Why might a tautomer not cause a mutation?tap
It may revert before the polymerase reads it, and proofreading and repair intervene.

And one to work out. With the tautomer 0.30 eV above the canonical form and kBT=0.0267k_BT = 0.0267 eV, what is the equilibrium tautomer fraction?

fraction ≈

Sources: P.-O. Löwdin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 35, 724 (1963). I. J. Kimsey et al., Nature 519, 315 (2015). L. Slocombe, M. Sacchi and J. Al-Khalili, Commun. Phys. 5, 109 (2022). Checked by code: e^(−0.30/0.02671) = 1.32 × 10⁻⁵.

Next · Chapter 172
Vision and single-photon detection in the retina

Your eye can sometimes register a single photon, slightly but measurably above chance.

Turn the page