163
Part Four · Quantum biology

Electron transfer and Marcus theory

Every breath you take ends in electron transfer: electrons hop, one at a time, along chains of metal centres and cofactors in mitochondria, tunnelling distances of 10–20 Å through protein. In 1956 Rudolph Marcus derived a rate law for such transfers with a strange prediction: make a reaction more favourable and, past a point, it gets slower. Chemists doubted it for nearly thirty years, until John Miller, Lawrence Calcaterra and Gerhard Closs observed this “inverted region” in 1984. Marcus received the 1992 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. Electron tunnelling in proteins is the clearest non-trivial quantum effect in biology.

On the plate: two energy parabolas and the rate they imply.

Deriving the Marcus rate

Electron transfer couples two states: electron on the donor, or on the acceptor. Each has a free-energy parabola in a collective nuclear coordinate, the arrangement of surrounding atoms and solvent. Their minima differ by the driving force ΔG∘\Delta G^\circ; the energy needed to rearrange the surroundings to the product’s geometry without moving the electron is the reorganization energy λ\lambda. The electron can only jump where the parabolas cross, conserving energy (Franck–Condon principle). Fermi’s golden rule (Chapter 45), averaged thermally over the crossing, gives

k=2πℏ∣HDA∣214πλkBTexp⁡[−(ΔG∘+λ)24λkBT]k = \frac{2\pi}{\hbar}|H_{DA}|^2\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi\lambda k_BT}}\exp\Big[-\frac{(\Delta G^\circ+\lambda)^2}{4\lambda k_BT}\Big]

where HDAH_{DA} is the electronic coupling between donor and acceptor. Established

The inverted region

Set ΔG∘=\Delta G^\circ = -0.40 eV and λ=\lambda = 0.80 eV. As the driving force increases, the crossing point descends to the bottom of the reactant parabola: the barrier vanishes at ΔG∘=−λ\Delta G^\circ = -\lambda, and the rate peaks. Beyond that, the crossing climbs the far side, the barrier returns, and the rate falls again, symmetric about −λ-\lambda in this classical form. Photosynthetic reaction centres exploit this: the forward charge separation sits near the peak, while the wasteful back-reaction, with much larger driving force, lies deep in the inverted region and is slow. Established

Tunnelling through protein

The coupling HDAH_{DA} comes from the electron tunnelling through the protein between donor and acceptor, so it decays exponentially with distance. Christopher Moser, Leslie Dutton and colleagues compiled rates across many proteins in 1992 into a simple ruler:

log⁡10k=13−0.6(R−3.6)−3.1(ΔG∘+λ)2λ\log_{10}k = 13 - 0.6(R - 3.6) - 3.1\frac{(\Delta G^\circ + \lambda)^2}{\lambda}

with RR the edge-to-edge distance in ångströms and energies in eV. The rate falls tenfold every 1.7 Å. Distance 10.0 Å. Beyond about 14 Å, single hops become too slow for biology, which is why respiratory and photosynthetic chains space their cofactors within that range. Harry Gray and Jay Winkler showed with ruthenium-labelled proteins that the protein’s structure, β-sheet or α-helix, tunes the decay. Established

What you now have

Marcus parabolas, the reorganization energy, the golden-rule rate law, the inverted region and its use in photosynthesis, electron tunnelling through proteins, and the Moser–Dutton distance ruler.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

Where does the rate peak?tap
At ΔG° = −λ, where the barrier vanishes.
What is the reorganization energy?tap
The energy to distort the surroundings to the product geometry without transferring the electron.
How fast does the rate fall with distance?tap
About tenfold per 1.7 Å.

And one to work out. With the Moser–Dutton ruler, at R=10R = 10 Å and ΔG∘=−λ\Delta G^\circ = -\lambda, what is log⁡10k\log_{10}k?

log₁₀ k =

Sources: R. A. Marcus, J. Chem. Phys. 24, 966 (1956). J. R. Miller, L. T. Calcaterra and G. L. Closs, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106, 3047 (1984). C. C. Moser et al., Nature 355, 796 (1992). H. B. Gray and J. R. Winkler, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 3534 (2005). Checked by code: the rate peaks at ΔG° = −λ and is symmetric about it; 0.6 per Å gives a decade per 1.67 Å.

Next · Chapter 164
Proton tunneling in enzymes

In some enzymes, hydrogen goes through the energy barrier rather than over it.

Turn the page