General relativity and quantum gravity: string theory, loop gravity, open problems
General relativity describes gravity as the curvature of spacetime, and it has passed every test: the bending of starlight, the timing of binary pulsars, the ripples of colliding black holes picked up by LIGO in 2015, the shadow of a black hole photographed in 2019. Quantum field theory describes everything else, equally well. Inside a black hole, or at the first instant of the Big Bang, both should apply at once, and they disagree. This last chapter of Part Two is about that disagreement, what is known for sure, and the candidate theories that try to resolve it.
On the plate: orbits around a black hole. Close in, Newton’s ellipses stop closing, and below a certain radius no stable orbit exists.
Gravity as geometry
Einstein’s equations, , say that energy and momentum, the stress tensor of Chapter 59, curve spacetime, and free bodies follow the straightest possible paths, geodesics, through it. Around a non-rotating mass the solution, found by Karl Schwarzschild in 1916, has a horizon at : 3 km for the Sun, if it were squeezed that small. Give a test body angular momentum 4.20 (units of ). Its orbit precesses; below there is no stable circular orbit, and inside matter spirals in. Established
Why gravity resists quantization
Newton’s constant has dimensions: in natural units , with the Planck mass GeV. Each graviton loop brings more powers of energy over , and new infinities appear at every order that cannot be absorbed into a finite number of constants. By Chapter 70’s criterion, gravity is non-renormalizable. That does not make it useless: as an effective field theory (Chapter 70), quantum general relativity gives reliable, tiny corrections below the Planck scale, such as the quantum correction to Newton’s potential. It fails near , where a more complete theory is needed. Established
Black holes are hot
In 1974 Stephen Hawking applied quantum field theory near a horizon and found that a black hole emits thermal radiation at temperature
Jacob Bekenstein had argued it must carry entropy proportional to its horizon area, . Set the mass to 0.0 (log₁₀ solar masses). A solar-mass black hole is at 62 nanokelvin, colder than the cosmic background, and would take years to evaporate. Small ones are hot and short-lived. Hawking radiation has never been observed from an astrophysical black hole; analogues in fluids and optics show the same mathematics. Established as theory; unobserved directly.
The information paradox
If a black hole formed from a pure quantum state evaporates into exactly thermal radiation, the final state is mixed: information is lost, contradicting unitarity (Chapter 31). Don Page showed in 1993 that if evaporation is unitary, the entanglement entropy of the radiation must rise and then fall, the Page curve, turning over halfway through. In 2019 calculations using semiclassical gravity with new saddle points, “islands”, reproduced the Page curve. Whether that resolves the paradox, and what it says about the interior, is debated. Speculative
Candidate theories
String theory replaces point particles with strings; one vibration is a graviton, and its loops are finite. It has produced deep results, such as the counting of black-hole entropy for special black holes and the AdS/CFT correspondence (Juan Maldacena, 1997), in which a gravitational theory in a curved space is exactly equivalent to a non-gravitational field theory on its boundary. It has made no confirmed prediction about our universe. Loop quantum gravity quantizes geometry directly, giving discrete areas and volumes, but has difficulty recovering smooth spacetime and has no confirmed predictions either. Other approaches, asymptotic safety, causal sets and more, each have advocates. Speculative, all of them.
What you now have
Spacetime curvature and geodesics, the Schwarzschild horizon and orbits, why gravity is non-renormalizable and how it works as an effective theory, Hawking temperature and Bekenstein entropy, the information paradox and Page curve, and the status of string theory, loop gravity and holography. Part Three turns from fundamental physics to the use of quantum mechanics as a technology: quantum information and computing.
· · ·
Three questions to carry with you.
And one to work out. K for one solar mass. What is it for a black hole of solar masses (about a quarter of the Moon’s mass)?
Sources: A. Einstein, Sitzungsber. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. 844 (1915). K. Schwarzschild, Sitzungsber. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. 189 (1916). B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO/Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 061102 (2016). Event Horizon Telescope, Astrophys. J. Lett. 875, L1 (2019). J. D. Bekenstein, Phys. Rev. D 7, 2333 (1973). S. W. Hawking, Nature 248, 30 (1974). D. N. Page, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3743 (1993). J. Maldacena, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998). S. M. Carroll, Spacetime and Geometry. Checked by code: r_s(Sun) = 2.95 km; T_H = 6.17×10⁻⁸ K; evaporation 2.1×10⁶⁷ yr; S/k = 1.05×10⁷⁷; M_Pl = 1.22×10¹⁹ GeV.