84
Part Two · Quantum fields and particles

CP violation and matter–antimatter asymmetry

In the first fraction of a second after the Big Bang, matter and antimatter were made in nearly equal amounts. Nearly: for every billion antiquarks there were a billion and one quarks. Then everything that could annihilate did, leaving radiation and that one-in-a-billion surplus. The surplus is every star, planet and person. For the surplus to arise, the laws of physics must treat matter and antimatter differently. They do. But not, as far as anyone has found, by nearly enough.

On the plate: a beam that starts as pure K⁰ mesons and turns partly into their antiparticles as it flies.

C, P, T and CPT

Three discrete transformations: C swaps particles and antiparticles; P mirrors space; T reverses time. The weak force violates C and P separately (Chapter 81): a left-handed neutrino becomes, under C, a left-handed antineutrino, which does not exist; under P, a right-handed neutrino, which does not interact. The combination CP turns it into a right-handed antineutrino, which does exist. For a while CP seemed exact.

The CPT theorem, proved from Lorentz invariance and locality in the 1950s, says the combination of all three is always a symmetry of a relativistic quantum field theory. So particles and antiparticles have exactly equal masses and lifetimes; the antiproton’s charge-to-mass ratio matches the proton’s to sixteen parts in a trillion. Established

Kaons that change into their antiparticles

The neutral kaon K0=dsˉK^0 = d\bar s and its antiparticle Kˉ0=sdˉ\bar K^0 = s\bar d can turn into each other through the weak force, a two-level system like the spin of Chapter 40. The states of definite lifetime are mixtures: a short-lived KSK_S (0.09 ns) and a long-lived KLK_L (51 ns). Start with pure K0K^0 and the probability of finding Kˉ0\bar K^0 oscillates at the mass difference Δm=3.5×10−12\Delta m = 3.5\times10^{-12} MeV, the smallest mass difference ever measured directly. Watch it for 2.00 ns.

If CP held, KLK_L would be pure CP-odd and could never decay to two pions. In 1964 James Cronin, Val Fitch and colleagues found that it does, about 2 in 1,000 times. CP is violated. Established

B mesons, and baryons

In the Standard Model, CP violation comes from the CKM phase (Chapter 83). It predicted large effects in B mesons, containing a bottom quark, and in 2001 the BaBar experiment at SLAC and Belle at KEK, each built for the purpose, measured them: sin⁡2β≈0.7\sin2\beta \approx 0.7, matching the triangle. Kobayashi and Maskawa received their Nobel Prize in 2008.

All these observations involved mesons. In 2025 LHCb reported the first CP violation in baryons, a 2.45% difference between the decays of the Λb\Lambda_b and its antiparticle, at 5.2 standard deviations. Established

What the universe needs

Andrei Sakharov listed in 1967 what any mechanism must have to make more matter than antimatter from a symmetric start. Check them off: , , . The Standard Model has all three in principle. But the CKM phase is suppressed by small quark mass differences and mixing angles; estimates of the resulting asymmetry come out around 10−2010^{-20}, against the observed 6×10−106\times10^{-10} baryons per photon. That is short by roughly ten orders of magnitude.

So there must be another source of CP violation. Candidates include CP violation among neutrinos, feeding leptogenesis through heavy partners, and extra Higgs fields. None is established. Established that the Standard Model falls short; Speculative what fills the gap.

What you now have

C, P and T and the CPT theorem, neutral-kaon mixing and its oscillation, the 1964 discovery of CP violation, B-meson and baryon CP violation, the Sakharov conditions, and why the Standard Model cannot explain the matter we are made of.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

What does CPT invariance guarantee?tap
Equal masses and lifetimes for particles and antiparticles.
What did Cronin and Fitch see?tap
The long-lived kaon decaying to two pions, which CP symmetry forbids.
Why isn’t the CKM phase enough for the universe?tap
Its effect on the early universe is suppressed by about ten orders of magnitude below the observed asymmetry.

And one to work out. With τS=0.0895\tau_S = 0.0895 ns and Δm=5.29\Delta m = 5.29 ns⁻¹ (in units of ħ), what is Δm τS\Delta m\,\tau_S?

Δm τ_S =

Sources: J. H. Christenson, J. W. Cronin, V. L. Fitch and R. Turlay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 138 (1964). A. D. Sakharov, JETP Lett. 5, 24 (1967). B. Aubert et al. (BaBar), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 091801 (2001); K. Abe et al. (Belle), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 091802 (2001). LHCb Collaboration, Nature 643 (2025) (Λ_b CP violation). BASE Collaboration, Nature 601, 53 (2022) (antiproton charge-to-mass ratio). Particle Data Group (kaon parameters; η_B = 6.1×10⁻¹⁰). Checked by code: P(K⁰ → K̄⁰) = 0.196, 0.265, 0.244 at 0.2, 0.6, 1.0 ns; Δm τ_S = 0.474.

Next · Chapter 85
Neutrino physics and oscillations

Neutrinos change identity in flight. That proves they have mass, which the Standard Model said they didn't.

Turn the page