79
Part Two · Quantum fields and particles

Asymptotic freedom and confinement

Hit a proton hard enough and the quarks inside behave as if they were almost free. Try to pull one out, and the force between it and the rest never weakens: it stays at about 15 tonnes, however far you pull, until the energy stored in the stretched field snaps into a new quark–antiquark pair. You never get a single quark, only more hadrons. The first half of that story is proven and won the 2004 Nobel Prize. Proving the second half is one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems, with a million dollars attached.

On the plate: two quarks joined by a tube of gluon field. Pull them apart.

Antiscreening

In QED, virtual pairs screen charge, and α\alpha grows at short distance (Chapter 70). In QCD, quark loops screen too, but gluon loops, possible because gluons carry colour (Chapter 75), do the opposite and win. At one loop,

μdαsdμ=−b02π αs2,b0=11−23nf\mu\frac{d\alpha_s}{d\mu} = -\frac{b_0}{2\pi}\,\alpha_s^2, \qquad b_0 = 11 - \tfrac23n_f

The 11 comes from gluons and is positive; each quark flavour subtracts 2/32/3. With up to 16 flavours b0>0b_0 > 0, and the coupling falls at high energy: asymptotic freedom. David Gross and Frank Wilczek, and independently David Politzer, found it in 1973. Established

The running strong coupling

Integrating gives αs(Q)=αs(M)/[1+b0αs(M)4πln⁡(Q2/M2)]\alpha_s(Q) = \alpha_s(M)/[1 + \frac{b_0\alpha_s(M)}{4\pi}\ln(Q^2/M^2)]. Anchor it at αs(mZ)=0.118\alpha_s(m_Z) = 0.118 and move to 1.96 (log₁₀ GeV). The one-loop curve gives 0.27 at the tau mass, where tau decays measure about 0.31, and 0.088 at 1 TeV, close to jet measurements. Higher loops close the gap. Going down, the coupling grows toward one near a few hundred MeV, the scale ΛQCD\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}, where perturbation theory stops working and protons are made.

Confinement

At large distance the gluon field between a quark and an antiquark does not spread like electric field lines; it squeezes into a narrow tube with constant energy per length, the string tension σ≈0.18\sigma \approx 0.18 GeV², about 0.9 GeV per fermi, a force near 15 tonnes. Stretch the tube by 0.60 fm. Past about 1.2 fm the stored energy exceeds what it takes to make a light quark pair, and the tube breaks into two mesons. This is why high-energy quarks emerge as jets of hadrons.

The evidence is strong: computer simulations of QCD on a spacetime lattice (Chapter 74) show the linear potential, and compute the proton’s mass from first principles to within a few percent. But no one has proven mathematically that Yang–Mills theory has a mass gap, a lightest particle with nonzero mass, which is what confinement requires. That is the Clay Institute’s Millennium Problem. Established in practice; Debated only in the sense of being unproven.

Where your mass comes from

The proton’s mass, almost all of it, is the energy of confined quarks and gluons (Chapter 77). Without quark masses at all, QCD would still produce protons with nearly the same mass, set by ΛQCD\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}, a scale that appears from the running of a dimensionless coupling: dimensional transmutation. A theory with no mass scale generates one, and that scale makes up most of the visible universe.

What you now have

Antiscreening by gluons, the one-loop β-function with b0=11−2nf/3b_0 = 11 - 2n_f/3, asymptotic freedom, the running of αs\alpha_s and ΛQCD\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}, confinement as a flux tube with string tension, string breaking and jets, lattice QCD, the mass-gap problem, and dimensional transmutation.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

Why does the strong coupling fall at high energy?tap
Gluon self-interaction antiscreens colour, outweighing quark screening when n_f ≤ 16.
What happens when you pull quarks apart?tap
The flux tube’s energy grows linearly until it breaks into a new quark–antiquark pair.
What is the Yang–Mills mass gap problem?tap
Prove that quantum Yang–Mills theory exists and that its lightest particle has positive mass.

And one to work out. What is b0=11−2nf/3b_0 = 11 - 2n_f/3 with all six quark flavours?

b₀ =

Sources: D. J. Gross and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 1343 (1973). H. D. Politzer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 1346 (1973). K. G. Wilson, Phys. Rev. D 10, 2445 (1974). S. Dürr et al., Science 322, 1224 (2008) (light hadron masses from lattice QCD). A. Jaffe and E. Witten, Clay Mathematics Institute problem description, Yang–Mills existence and mass gap. Particle Data Group, QCD review (α_s(m_Z) = 0.118). Checked by code: one-loop α_s 0.273 (1.777 GeV), 0.203 (5 GeV), 0.088 (1 TeV); σ = 0.18 GeV² = 0.91 GeV/fm ≈ 1.5×10⁵ N.

Next · Chapter 80
Hadrons and the quark model

Gell-Mann predicted the Ω⁻ from a gap in a pattern. It was found in 1964.

Turn the page