55
Part Two · Quantum fields and particles

Relativistic quantum mechanics

Try to pin an electron down more and more tightly. In ordinary quantum mechanics this costs momentum, by the uncertainty principle, and nothing worse. But squeeze it into a region much smaller than about 400 femtometres, its Compton wavelength, and the momentum spread carries enough energy to create a new electron and its antiparticle out of nothing. You do not get a better-located electron. You get three particles. Quantum mechanics and special relativity, taken together, will not allow a fixed number of particles. This chapter shows why, and why the answer is quantum field theory.

On the plate: the energy it costs to confine an electron, rising past the threshold for making a pair.

Natural units

Particle physicists set ℏ=c=1\hbar = c = 1. Then energy, mass, momentum and inverse length all share one unit, usually MeV or GeV, and the single conversion you need is

ℏc=197.327 MeV fm\hbar c = 197.327\ \text{MeV fm}

A mass of 197 MeV corresponds to a length of 1 fm. Convert 938 MeV into a length. Cross sections come out in GeV−2\text{GeV}^{-2}, and 1 GeV−2=0.3891\ \text{GeV}^{-2} = 0.389 millibarn. From here on, the book writes mm for mc2mc^2 and 1/m1/m for ℏ/mc\hbar/mc without comment. Established

Four-vectors and the metric

Gather time and space into xμ=(t,x)x^\mu = (t, \mathbf x) and energy and momentum into pμ=(E,p)p^\mu = (E, \mathbf p). This book uses the metric ημν=diag(+1,−1,−1,−1)\eta_{\mu\nu} = \mathrm{diag}(+1, -1, -1, -1), so

p⋅p=E2−∣p∣2=m2,p⋅x=Et−p⋅xp\cdot p = E^2 - |\mathbf p|^2 = m^2, \qquad p\cdot x = Et - \mathbf p\cdot\mathbf x

These products are the same in every inertial frame (Chapter 17). A plane wave e−ip⋅xe^{-ip\cdot x} is then manifestly relativistic. The relation E2=p2+m2E^2 = p^2 + m^2 has two branches, E=±p2+m2E = \pm\sqrt{p^2 + m^2}, drawn on the plate as a hyperbola above and its mirror below, separated by a gap of 2m2m. The lower branch will not go away.

A single relativistic particle leaks

The obvious way to make a relativistic Schrödinger equation is to keep only positive energies: i∂tψ=−∇2+m2 ψi\partial_t\psi = \sqrt{-\nabla^2 + m^2}\,\psi. Start a particle exactly at the origin and ask for its amplitude to be found at distance rr a time tt later. For r>tr > t, outside the light cone, it should vanish. It doesn’t: it falls as e−mr2−t2e^{-m\sqrt{r^2 - t^2}}, small but not zero.

Set the mass to 1.0. The leak extends about one Compton wavelength 1/m1/m beyond the light cone. A one-particle theory violates causality. In quantum field theory the same leak is cancelled exactly by the amplitude for an antiparticle to travel the other way, and measurements at spacelike separation commute (Chapter 60). Established

The price of confinement

Localize a particle to Δx\Delta x. Its momentum spread is at least 1/(2Δx)1/(2\Delta x) in natural units, and its energy spread rises with it. When that energy exceeds 2m2m, the particle and its surroundings have enough energy to create a particle–antiparticle pair. Set the confinement to 100 fm for an electron.

On this rough estimate the threshold is crossed near 70 fm, a fraction of the reduced Compton wavelength ℏ/mc=386\hbar/mc = 386 fm; for the proton the same scale is 0.21 fm. The exact number depends on how you define the spread; the scale does not. Below it, “the position of one electron” stops being meaningful, because there need not be just one.

Why fields

Three facts now point the same way. Particle number is not conserved at high energy; colliders make particles by the dozen. Negative-energy solutions cannot be thrown away, because a consistent, causal theory needs them. And causality requires particles and antiparticles to cancel each other’s leaks. A theory with these properties has a field at every point of space, whose excitations are the particles and whose equations are relativistic. Particles become quanta of fields, as photons were already quanta of the electromagnetic field in Chapter 36. The next chapters build such theories, one equation at a time.

What you now have

Natural units and ℏc=197.3\hbar c = 197.3 MeV fm, four-vectors in the metric (+,−,−,−)(+,-,-,-), the two energy branches, the causality leak of one-particle theory, the Compton wavelength as the scale of pair creation, and the case for quantum fields.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

What length corresponds to 1 GeV?tap
ħc/1 GeV ≈ 0.197 fm.
Why does a one-particle relativistic theory fail?tap
Its amplitude leaks outside the light cone, and it cannot account for particle creation at energies above 2m.
Below what size does locating one electron stop making sense?tap
About its Compton wavelength, ħ/mc ≈ 386 fm.

And one to work out. The proton’s mass is 938.27 MeV. What is its reduced Compton wavelength ℏ/mc\hbar/mc, in fm?

λ =fm

Sources: M. E. Peskin and D. V. Schroeder, An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory, ch. 2. M. D. Schwartz, Quantum Field Theory and the Standard Model, ch. 1–2. CODATA 2022 constants. Checked by code: ħc = 197.327 MeV fm; ħ/mc = 386.16 fm (electron), 0.2103 fm (proton); 1 GeV⁻² = 0.3894 mb.

Next · Chapter 56
The Klein–Gordon equation

Schrödinger tried this equation first and threw it away. It came back to describe the Higgs.

Turn the page