WKB approximation
In 1913 Bohr quantized the atom with a rule that seemed arbitrary: the action around an orbit must be a whole number of Planck’s constants. Thirteen years later, the Schrödinger equation replaced it. But Bohr’s rule was not wrong. It is the first term of an expansion of the Schrödinger equation in powers of , and with one small correction it predicts energies to a fraction of a percent. This chapter derives it, and uses it to explain neutrons that bounce on a mirror in quantized steps of a few micrometres.
On the plate: an exact wavefunction, and the envelope the semiclassical method predicts for it.
Waves with slowly changing wavelength
Where the potential is constant, with . If changes slowly, let change too. Substituting and expanding in powers of gives, to the first two orders,
This is the Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin (WKB) approximation of 1926. The phase advances by the local wavenumber; the amplitude goes as , so , which is the classical rule that a particle is most likely found where it moves slowest. Step through the states of a quartic well, , with 8. The amber envelope is WKB’s; the white wave is the exact solution.
Where it breaks
At a turning point, where , and the formula blows up. The wavelength is no longer short compared with the distance over which it changes. The cure: near the turning point, the potential is nearly a straight line, and the Schrödinger equation for a linear potential is solved exactly by the Airy function. Matching the Airy function to WKB on both sides gives the connection formulas: the oscillating wave inside joins the decaying one outside with a phase of .
The plate zooms in on one turning point. Amber is WKB, which diverges; white is the exact Airy function, which passes smoothly into the wall.
Bohr’s rule, corrected
Fit the wave between two turning points, with a phase of lost at each, and you get
The area enclosed by the classical orbit in the plane of position and momentum is a whole number of , plus a half. That half is the zero-point energy of Chapter 35, which Bohr’s original rule missed. Choose a potential: , or .
For the harmonic oscillator, WKB is exact. For the quartic well it is 18% off for the ground state, 1.3% for the next, and 0.06% by : better and better as the motion becomes more classical. Established
Neutrons on a mirror
A particle above a hard floor in gravity has the potential above and a wall below. The exact levels involve the zeros of the Airy function; WKB, with a wall on one side, gives instead of and matches them to within 1% even for the lowest.
For neutrons, the natural length is 5.87 µm, and the lowest states have heights of about 13.7, 24.0, 32.4 and 39.8 µm. In 2002 Valery Nesvizhevsky and colleagues at the Institut Laue–Langevin sent ultracold neutrons over a mirror under an absorbing ceiling. Lowering the ceiling below about 15 µm stopped transmission almost completely: the neutrons could not fit. Gravity, the weakest force, quantized in the lab. Established
Tunnelling, approximately
Under a barrier, becomes imaginary and WKB’s wave becomes a decaying exponential, . So the transmission through any smooth barrier is roughly
This is Gamow’s factor for alpha decay from Chapter 34. Applied to a Coulomb barrier, it gives the Geiger–Nuttall law. The same formula sets the rates of fusion in the Sun and of hydrogen transfer in some enzymes, which Part Four will examine.
When to trust it
The condition is that the wavelength changes little over one wavelength: . That fails near turning points, at sharp steps, and for low quantum numbers. Michael Berry and Kenneth Mount showed in 1972 that the full series in is asymptotic, like the perturbation series of Chapter 44, and that its failures encode real physics, such as the exponentially small reflection from a smooth step that no finite order captures.
What you now have
The WKB wavefunction and its amplitude, turning points and Airy functions, the corrected Bohr–Sommerfeld rule, the quantum bouncer and the neutron experiment, the Gamow factor, and the limits of validity.
· · ·
Three questions to carry with you.
And one to work out. The neutron’s natural length in gravity is µm, and the first Airy zero is 2.338. How high is the lowest state, , in µm?
Sources: G. Wentzel, Z. Phys. 38, 518 (1926); H. A. Kramers, Z. Phys. 39, 828 (1926); L. Brillouin, C. R. Acad. Sci. 183, 24 (1926). M. V. Berry and K. E. Mount, Rep. Prog. Phys. 35, 315 (1972). V. V. Nesvizhevsky et al., Nature 415, 297 (2002). Checked by code: quartic well exact 0.668, 2.394, 4.697 against WKB 0.546, 2.364, 4.671; Airy zeros 2.338, 4.088, 5.521 against WKB 2.320, 4.082, 5.517; ℓ₀ = 5.87 µm, heights 13.7, 24.0, 32.4, 39.8 µm.