38
Part One · Quantum mechanics

The hydrogen atom

Heat hydrogen gas and look at its glow through a prism: a red line, a blue-green one, two violet ones, at wavelengths measured in the nineteenth century to a few parts in a hundred thousand. Solve one equation, the Schrödinger equation with the Coulomb force, and those wavelengths come out to the same precision. Then look harder, and the lines turn out to be split by tiny amounts the equation does not predict. One of those splittings, measured in 1947, launched quantum electrodynamics.

On the plate: hydrogen’s electron, drawn as a cloud of points sampled from its probability.

The energies

Put V=−e2/4πε0rV = -e^2/4\pi\varepsilon_0 r into the radial equation of Chapter 37. Use the Bohr radius a0=0.529a_0 = 0.529 Å as the unit of length. Far out, u∼e−κru \sim e^{-\kappa r}; near the nucleus, u∼rℓ+1u \sim r^{\ell+1}. What is left is again a power series, and once more it must stop or the wavefunction cannot be normalized. It stops only when κa0=1/n\kappa a_0 = 1/n for a whole number n>ℓn > \ell:

En=−13.6 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.6\ \text{eV}}{n^2}

with ℓ=0,1,…,n−1\ell = 0, 1, \dots, n-1 and m=−ℓ,…,ℓm = -\ell, \dots, \ell. That is Bohr’s formula of Chapter 24, now with a real wavefunction behind it. The energy depends only on nn. Counting ℓ\ell and mm, level nn holds n2n^2 states, more than the 2ℓ+12\ell + 1 rotation alone requires. The extra degeneracy comes from a hidden symmetry special to the 1/r1/r force, the same one that keeps planetary orbits from precessing. Established

The orbitals

Choose n=n = 2, ℓ=\ell = 1 and m=m = 0. Each dot is one possible place to find the electron, drawn at random with the true probability, so dense regions are likely ones.

The shape comes from the spherical harmonic; the layering comes from the radial function, which has n−ℓ−1n - \ell - 1 nodes, spherical shells where the electron is never found. A 2s orbital has one inside it; you can see the gap in the cloud.

How far out is the electron?

The probability of finding the electron between rr and r+drr + dr is r2∣R(r)∣2drr^2|R(r)|^2dr: the r2r^2 counts the area of the shell. The plate plots it for the state you chose. For the ground state the peak is at exactly a0a_0, Bohr’s radius, but the average is 32a0\tfrac32 a_0, because the tail reaches out.

In general ⟨r⟩=12[3n2−ℓ(ℓ+1)] a0\langle r\rangle = \tfrac12[3n^2 - \ell(\ell+1)]\,a_0: atoms grow as n2n^2. A hydrogen atom with n=100n = 100, a Rydberg atom, is about a micrometre across, the size of a bacterium, and such atoms are now used as sensitive detectors of electric fields and as qubits.

The virial theorem

For any potential that goes as a power of rr, the averages of kinetic and potential energy are locked together. For 1/r1/r, 2⟨T⟩=−⟨V⟩2\langle T\rangle = -\langle V\rangle. So ⟨T⟩=−En\langle T\rangle = -E_n and ⟨V⟩=2En\langle V\rangle = 2E_n. In the ground state the electron has 13.6 eV of kinetic energy and −27.2 eV of potential energy. Binding an electron more tightly makes it move faster, not slower.

DeeperFrom Chapter 31, ddt⟨r⋅p⟩=⟨2T−r⋅∇V⟩\frac{d}{dt}\langle \mathbf r\cdot\mathbf p\rangle = \langle 2T - \mathbf r\cdot\nabla V\rangle, which vanishes in a stationary state. For V∝rkV \propto r^k, r⋅∇V=kV\mathbf r\cdot\nabla V = kV, so 2⟨T⟩=k⟨V⟩2\langle T\rangle = k\langle V\rangle; k=−1k = -1 for Coulomb, k=2k = 2 for the oscillator.

The spectrum, predicted

A jump from level n2n_2 down to n1n_1 emits a photon with 1/λ=RH(1/n12−1/n22)1/\lambda = R_H(1/n_1^2 - 1/n_2^2). Choose the lower level: (ultraviolet), (visible) or (infrared).

With the reduced mass of the electron and proton, the predicted red Balmer line is at 656.47 nm in vacuum; it is measured at 656.46 nm. They differ by about one part in fifty thousand, and that small remainder is real physics, the subject of the next passage.

The splitting that launched QED

Looked at closely, the n=2n = 2 level is not one level. Relativity and the electron’s spin, which Dirac’s equation of 1928 includes, split it: the 2P3/22P_{3/2} states sit about 11 GHz above the rest. Dirac’s theory says 2S1/22S_{1/2} and 2P1/22P_{1/2} should stay exactly together.

In 1947 Willis Lamb and Robert Retherford shone microwaves on hydrogen and found that they do not. 2S1/22S_{1/2} lies about 1058 MHz higher. Explaining that Lamb shift, which comes from the electron’s interaction with the fluctuating vacuum electromagnetic field, forced the development of quantum electrodynamics by Bethe, Feynman, Schwinger and Tomonaga. Part Five derives it. Established

How big is a proton?

Because s electrons reach the nucleus (Chapter 37), hydrogen’s levels depend slightly on the proton’s size. In 2010 Randolf Pohl’s team replaced the electron with a muon, 207 times heavier, which orbits 200 times closer and feels the proton’s size far more. They found a radius of 0.842 fm, against 0.877 fm from ordinary hydrogen and electron scattering: a gap of more than five standard deviations, later seven.

Since then, most new measurements on ordinary hydrogen and new electron-scattering experiments have found the smaller value, and CODATA now recommends 0.841 fm. A few older results still disagree, and some tension remains in the data. Debated, leaning toward resolved, with the smaller radius.

What you now have

The hydrogen energies and their n2n^2 degeneracy, orbitals and radial nodes, radial probabilities and ⟨r⟩\langle r\rangle, the virial theorem, the spectral series, fine structure and the Lamb shift, and the proton-radius puzzle.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

Why is the most probable radius of 1s equal to a₀ but ⟨r⟩ = 1.5 a₀?tap
The distribution r²|R|² is lopsided, with a long tail outwards that pulls the average beyond the peak.
What did the Lamb shift show?tap
That 2S₁/₂ and 2P₁/₂ are not degenerate, an effect of the quantized electromagnetic vacuum that Dirac’s theory misses.
Why does muonic hydrogen probe the proton’s size so well?tap
The heavy muon orbits about 200 times closer, so it spends far more time overlapping the proton.

And one to work out. A hydrogen-like ion with nuclear charge ZZ has En=−13.6 Z2/n2E_n = -13.6\,Z^2/n^2 eV. What is the ground-state energy of Li²⁺ (Z=3Z = 3), in eV?

E₁ =eV

Sources: W. E. Lamb and R. C. Retherford, Phys. Rev. 72, 241 (1947). H. A. Bethe and E. E. Salpeter, Quantum Mechanics of One- and Two-Electron Atoms. R. Pohl et al., Nature 466, 213 (2010). W. Xiong et al. (PRad), Nature 575, 147 (2019). N. Bezginov et al., Science 365, 1007 (2019). CODATA 2022 recommended values. Checked by code: R_H = 10 967 758 m⁻¹; Hα 656.47 nm, Hβ 486.27 nm, Lyman α 121.57 nm; all radial functions normalized; ⟨r⟩ = (3n² − ℓ(ℓ+1))/2; most probable r: 1s 1.0, 2p 4.0, 3d 9.0.

Next · Chapter 39
Angular momentum

From three commutators alone, you can prove that spin-½ is allowed.

Turn the page