25
Part One · Quantum mechanics

de Broglie waves and the double slit

Shoot a single electron at a wall with two narrow slits in it, and see where it lands on a screen behind. That is the whole experiment. People have argued about what it means for a hundred years, and by the end of this chapter you will have run it yourself.

Look at the plate. On the left is the gun, which fires electrons one at a time. In the middle is the wall, with its two slits. On the right is the screen, which glows wherever an electron strikes it. The tall panel beyond is the same screen turned to face you, so you can watch the hits pile up.

This is the double-slit experiment. Feynman thought it held the central mystery of quantum mechanics, and that once you understood it, the rest would follow.

One electron

Now . Watch it leave the gun, reach the wall, and strike the screen.

It lands in one place and leaves one dot, the way a very small bullet would. Whatever an electron is, it arrives like a particle.

A few more

Fire , and , and . That makes 0 so far.

Each one lands somewhere new, and nothing tells you in advance where the next will go. It looks random. Keep that word in mind.

A guess

Before going further, commit to a prediction. If electrons are bullets, each passes through either the top slit or the bottom one. After two thousand of them, I think the screen will show , or , or .

Tap the phrase you believe. Or don’t; read on and see.

Your guess: two bands. Read on to see.

Your guess: many stripes. Read on to see.

Your guess: one soft glow. Read on to see.

Two thousand

Press and , or . The face-on screen fills as you watch.

Stripes. Bright, dark, bright, dark, fading towards the edges. You guessed two bands, the bullet answer, which is what nearly everyone guesses.You guessed stripes, which almost nobody does.You guessed a single glow; the screen disagrees.

Every electron still landed as one dot. The stripes appear only when thousands are added together.

The strange part

I have closed the top slit. Tap to open or close it, and compare.

With one slit, the stripes vanish into a single smooth band. Now think about a spot where a dark stripe used to be. With one slit open, electrons land there. Open the second slit and fewer land there.

More ways through, fewer hits. Bullets cannot do that. Waves can.

The wave

Both slits are open again, and the plate now shows the wave. Tap to hide it or bring it back.

Each electron travels as a wave, and the wave goes through both slits. Behind the wall the two halves overlap. Where crest meets crest the wave is strong, and you get a bright stripe. Where crest meets trough the two cancel, and you get a dark one. Follow the bright rays: they end on the bright stripes.

The wave does not say where the electron is. It sets the odds of where it will land. When it reaches the screen, it still makes one dot.

NotePhysicists call this wave the wavefunction. The chance of a hit at a spot is the square of the wave’s size there. Established

Peeking

Now cheat. Put a detector beside each slit, so that every electron flashes the one it passes. are on; tap to switch them off and on.

With the detectors on, the stripes are gone, and you get the bullet answer after all: two blurred bands, overlapping. Knowing the path destroys the stripes. You can have one or the other, never both.

DeeperNo one has to look at the detector. Any physical record of the path entangles the electron with its surroundings, and the two halves of its wave can no longer interfere. This is decoherence. Established

Your turn

Faster electrons have shorter waves, and shorter waves make tighter stripes. The small marks beside the screen show where the dark stripes fall at one particular energy.

Drag this number sideways. The electrons now carry 110 eV, which gives them a wavelength of 0.117 nm. Find the energy where the dark lanes of the wave meet the marks, then to check.

The dark lanes are too close together. Lower the energy.

That is it: 54 electronvolts, and a wavelength of 0.167 nanometres. It is the energy Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer used in 1927, when they first caught electrons behaving as waves. Established

The rule behind the dial is de Broglie’s: a particle with momentum pp has wavelength λ=h/p\lambda = h/p, where hh is Planck’s constant. More energy, more momentum, shorter wave.

Deeper

For an electron with kinetic energy EE far below its rest energy, p=2meEp = \sqrt{2 m_e E}, so

λ=h2meE≈1.226 nmE/eV\lambda = \frac{h}{\sqrt{2 m_e E}} \approx \frac{1.226\ \text{nm}}{\sqrt{E/\text{eV}}}

The stripe spacing on the screen is Δy≈λL/d\Delta y \approx \lambda L / d, with LL the distance to the screen and dd the gap between the slits.

What you found

An electron travels as a wave, through both slits at once, and arrives as a single dot. The wave sets the odds. Watching which way it went wipes the stripes out.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you. Answer each in your head, then tap to check.

Why does a dark stripe get fewer hits with two slits open than with one?tap
The waves from the two slits arrive there crest-to-trough and cancel, so the chance of landing there drops.
What happened when you watched which slit each electron used?tap
The stripes vanished, leaving two blurred bands. Path information destroys the interference.
You raise the electron energy. What do the stripes do?tap
They squeeze closer together: more energy, a shorter wavelength, tighter stripes.

And one to work out. Using λ≈1.226 nm/E/eV\lambda \approx 1.226\ \text{nm}/\sqrt{E/\text{eV}}, what wavelength does a 100 eV electron have?

λ =nm

Sources: L. de Broglie, thesis (1924). C. Davisson and L. H. Germer, Phys. Rev. 30, 705 (1927). A. Tonomura et al., Am. J. Phys. 57, 117 (1989). Wavelengths from CODATA constants: λ(54 eV) = 0.1669 nm, λ(100 eV) = 0.1226 nm.

Next · Chapter 26
The wavefunction and probability

You can never see ψ. Yet it predicts every count in every detector.

Turn the page