The crisis in classical physics
By classical physics, every atom in your body should have collapsed about a hundred-billionth of a second after it formed. In April 1900 Lord Kelvin told the Royal Institution that the theory of heat and light was beautiful and nearly complete, apart from two small “clouds” on the horizon. Within five years those clouds had become relativity and quantum mechanics.
Part Zero gave you the classical toolkit. This chapter gathers, in one place, the five places where it fails, and fails badly. Each failure is a clue, and each clue will be solved in the chapters that follow.
The dashboard
The plate shows four classical predictions, in grey, against what experiments actually found, in amber. Look at each in turn: , , and . Or .
In every panel the classical curve is not slightly off. It has the wrong shape.
Failure one: the glowing oven
Equipartition gives every mode of light in a hot box the same average energy , and there are ever more modes at short wavelengths. The predicted brightness rises without limit towards the ultraviolet, the Rayleigh–Jeans law. Real ovens and stars glow with a peak and then fade. Chapter 22 shows how Max Planck fixed it in 1900 by letting energy come only in lumps . Established
Failure two: light that knocks out electrons
Shine light on a clean metal and electrons fly out. A wave carries energy in proportion to its brightness, so brighter light should throw electrons out faster. It does not. Brighter light throws out more electrons, at the same speeds; only changing the colour changes their speed, and below a certain frequency nothing comes out at all, however bright the light. Chapter 23 takes this apart. Established
Failure three: barcodes of light
Heat a gas or pass a spark through it and it glows, but not in a smooth rainbow. It emits a few sharp colours, a different barcode for each element. Hydrogen’s visible lines sit at 656, 486, 434 and 410 nm. A classical electron orbiting a nucleus could radiate at any frequency, smeared continuously as it spirals. Nothing in classical physics picks out particular colours. Chapter 24 decodes hydrogen’s barcode. Established
Failure four: atoms should not last
Chapter 16 showed that an orbiting electron radiates and spirals inward in about seconds. There is a deeper problem too. Try to build the size of an atom from the constants classical physics offers, the electron’s charge and mass and the speed of light. The only length they make is the classical electron radius, m, nearly twenty thousand times smaller than a real atom.
Add Planck’s constant and the right size appears at once: m. Atoms are as big as they are because of . The ratio of the two lengths is exactly , where is the fine-structure constant you will meet again.
Failure five: cold solids
Equipartition predicts that every solid needs the same heat per mole to warm by one degree, J/(mol K): the Dulong–Petit law. Copper and lead obey it at room temperature. Diamond needs only about 6.1. And as any solid is cooled towards absolute zero, its heat capacity drops towards zero too. Classical physics has no way for a vibrating atom to refuse heat. Einstein’s quantized oscillators of Chapter 19 do. Established
What classical physics got right
It would be wrong to throw the old physics away. Conservation of energy and momentum survive untouched. Maxwell’s equations survive. Hamilton’s equations survive as the shape of quantum dynamics. What fails is the assumption that energy can be divided as finely as you like, and that a particle has a definite path. Quantum mechanics replaces those two assumptions and keeps nearly everything else.
· · ·
Three questions to carry with you.
And one to work out. Using 3R with J/(mol K), what heat capacity does Dulong–Petit predict per mole?
Sources: Lord Kelvin, Phil. Mag. 2, 1 (1901). A. Pais, Inward Bound. H. Kragh, Quantum Generations. NIST data for diamond (C_p ≈ 6.1 J/mol K at 298 K). Checked by code: a₀/r_e = 1/α² = 18,779; 3R = 24.94 J/(mol K).