1
Part Zero · Foundations

How to learn physics: the method of this book

Stand on the Moon with a geologist’s hammer in one hand and a falcon feather in the other. Hold them at the same height and let go of both at once. Before you watch, decide what happens. I think , or , or .

Choose one before you look. It matters more than it seems.

Now .

What happened

They land together. Commander David Scott did exactly this on the Moon on 2 August 1971, during Apollo 15, live on television. Established

You called it. You expected the hammer to win, as almost everyone’s instinct says. You expected the feather to win, which is a brave guess. On Earth the feather drifts down because air pushes back on it. Try it: , then .

Notice what the guess did. Because you had committed to an answer, the result either confirmed something or surprised you, and a surprise is something you remember. That minute contains the method of this whole book: predict, then play, then explain.

Why rereading fails

The most popular way to study is to read the material again. It feels like learning, because the words become familiar. Familiar is not the same as remembered.

In 2013 John Dunlosky and colleagues reviewed hundreds of studies of ten common study techniques. Two came out on top: practice testing, meaning pulling an answer out of your own memory, and distributed practice, meaning spreading reviews out over days. Rereading and highlighting came near the bottom. Established

Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke showed the effect cleanly in 2006. Students who tested themselves on a passage remembered more of it a week later than students who spent the same time rereading it, even though the rereaders felt more confident. Established

Spacing, in a picture

The plate shows a simple model of memory. Each time you recall something, it fades more slowly afterwards. Compare with . Look at what is left on day 30.

Cramming keeps you sharp for a day or two. Spacing keeps you sharp for a month, with only one extra review.

A model, not a lawHere memory decays exponentially, and each review makes it last two and a half times longer. Real forgetting is messier. The model is only here to show the direction the studies point in.

That is why every chapter ends with a few questions to carry, and why later chapters ask you about earlier ones.

Thinking with units

The second tool in this book costs nothing and catches most mistakes. Every physical quantity carries units, and an equation is only possible if the units on both sides match.

Take a pendulum. Its period, the time for one full swing, can only depend on things you could change: the length of the string LL, the strength of gravity gg, and the mass of the bob mm. Suppose T∝La gb mcT \propto L^{a}\, g^{b}\, m^{c}. A period is measured in seconds, so the powers must cancel every unit except seconds.

Find the powers. Length to the power 1.0, gravity to the power 1.0, mass to the power 1.0.

The plate shows each unit’s leftover power. Make metres and kilograms vanish, and leave seconds to the first power.

The answer, and a surprise

The only choice that works is a=12a = \tfrac12, b=−12b = -\tfrac12, c=0c = 0, so T∝L/gT \propto \sqrt{L/g}. The full calculation adds a factor of 2π2\pi that units alone cannot give you:

T=2πLgT = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}}

Set the string to 1.00 m and it swings once every 2.01 s. A metre-long pendulum ticks almost exactly every two seconds, which is why grandfather clocks are about that tall.

Look at the mass: its power is zero. The period does not care how heavy the bob is, for the same reason the hammer and the feather fell together. Units told you something true about nature before you did any physics.

Estimating anything

The third tool is the Fermi estimate, named after Enrico Fermi, who liked to ask questions such as how many piano tuners work in Chicago. You will rarely know the answer, but you can almost always get within a factor of ten.

How many atoms are in one of your cells? A typical cell is about 10 µm across. Treat it as a cube of water: volume d3d^3, a thousand kilograms per cubic metre, eighteen grams per mole of water, three atoms per molecule, and 6×10236\times10^{23} molecules per mole.

The answer comes out at about 10^14 atoms: a hundred trillion. The plate puts it on a ladder of powers of ten, beside the number of people on Earth and the stars in our galaxy.

The smallest length

Units can also point at physics nobody has reached. Quantum mechanics brings in Planck’s constant ℏ\hbar, gravity brings Newton’s GG, and relativity brings the speed of light cc. There is exactly one way to combine them into a length:

ℓP=ℏGc3≈1.6×10−35 m\ell_P = \sqrt{\frac{\hbar G}{c^{3}}} \approx 1.6\times10^{-35}\ \text{m}

That is the Planck length, about twenty powers of ten smaller than a proton. The number itself is certain. What it means is not: many physicists expect space and time to stop behaving smoothly near this scale, but no experiment has come close to testing that. Debated

DeeperCheck the units yourself. ℏ\hbar is in joule-seconds, GG in m3 kg−1 s−2\text{m}^3\,\text{kg}^{-1}\,\text{s}^{-2}, and cc in metres per second. Writing a joule as kg m2 s−2\text{kg}\,\text{m}^2\,\text{s}^{-2}, the product ℏG/c3\hbar G/c^3 comes out in square metres.

How to read this book

Every chapter works the way this one did. Words printed do something on the plate when you tap them. Numbers on an amber background can be dragged. As you read, the plate changes by itself, so you are never stuck waiting.

The Aa at the top changes how deep the text goes. Intuition keeps only the story, Standard adds the main equations, and Deep adds full derivations. Claims carry a label: Established for settled results, Debated for open arguments, and Speculative for ideas that are not yet tested.

· · ·

Three questions to carry with you.

Why does rereading feel effective even when it is not?tap
Rereading makes the words familiar, and familiarity feels like knowing. Recalling without looking is what actually strengthens memory.
Why does a pendulum’s period not depend on the mass of the bob?tap
No other quantity in the problem carries kilograms, so mass cannot appear in a formula for a time. Physically, a heavier bob feels a larger pull but is just as much harder to move.
What is a Fermi estimate for?tap
Getting the right power of ten from rough, honest guesses, so you know whether an answer is plausible before you calculate it exactly.

And one to work out. A pendulum is 0.25 m long. How many seconds does one swing take? Use g=9.81 m/s2g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2.

T =s

Sources: J. Dunlosky et al., Psychol. Sci. Public Interest 14, 4 (2013). H. L. Roediger and J. D. Karpicke, Psychol. Sci. 17, 249 (2006). S. Freeman et al., PNAS 111, 8410 (2014). NASA, Apollo 15 hammer–feather drop (1971). Planck length from CODATA constants: 1.616×10⁻³⁵ m.

Next · Chapter 2
Calculus refresher

How does a calculator compute sin(0.3)?

Turn the page